Skip to content

Rent vs. Buy Net Worth Visualizer

Compare the long-run net worth of buying a home against renting and investing the difference, including all the costs owners often forget.

100% private — calculations run in your browser and nothing is sent to Plot Your Money.

Buying

$
%
%
yrs
%

As a % of the home's value.

%

As a % of the home's value. 1–2% is a common planning range.

%

Renting & investing

$
%
%

Return earned on the down payment and any monthly savings the cheaper option frees up.

yrs

After 15 years

Buying wins

by $59,938 in net worth

Break-even year

Year 8

First year buying's net worth overtakes renting.

Net worth

Rent & invest

$341,549

Buy

$401,487

Year-1 monthly cost

Rent

$2,200

Own

$2,734

Mortgage alone: $2,023/mo

Cash needed upfront to buy

$92,000

Down payment plus closing costs — the renter invests this amount instead.

Net worth: buy vs. rent

Annual housing cost: owning vs. renting

Year-by-year comparison

Net worth assumes the home is sold and investments cashed out at the end of each year, after selling costs and any taxes you set.

Rent vs. buy: how to compare them fairly

Last reviewed 16 November 2026 · Educational content, not financial advice.

A fair way to compare renting and buying

Comparing a monthly rent with a monthly mortgage payment is misleading. Owners also pay property tax, insurance, maintenance and transaction costs, while renters keep their down payment invested. The honest question is: after a given number of years, which choice leaves you with more net worth?

This calculator follows two people with identical budgets. The buyer spends the down payment and closing costs, then pays the mortgage, tax and upkeep each month. The renter invests that same upfront cash and pays rent. Each month, whoever has the cheaper housing invests the difference. At the end of each year we compare the buyer's home equity (after selling costs) plus investments with the renter's portfolio.

The formulas

Buyer cost (month)  = Mortgage payment + Value × (tax% + upkeep%) ÷ 12
                      + PMI (while loan > 80% of price) − Interest × relief%
Renter cost (month) = Rent (rises by rent inflation once a year)
Difference          = |Buyer cost − Renter cost| → invested by the cheaper side

Buy net worth  = Home value × (1 − selling cost%) − Loan balance + Buyer investments
Rent net worth = (Down payment + Closing costs) grown + Renter investments
(investment gains and home sale gains minus any tax rates you set)

Home values and investments grow monthly at the effective rate (1 + R)^(1/12) − 1. The mortgage uses the standard amortization formula M = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n). The break-even year is the first year in which the buyer's net worth exceeds the renter's; if the lead changes again later, every change is listed.

Worked example

A 400,000 home is compared with renting a similar place for 2,200 a month:

  • 20% down payment (80,000) plus 3% closing costs (12,000): 92,000 upfront, which the renter invests instead.
  • Mortgage of 320,000 at 6.5% over 30 years: 2,022.62 a month.
  • Add 1.1% property tax and 1% maintenance and insurance. In year one, owning costs about 32,805, or roughly 2,734 a month. That is about 534 more than rent, and the renter invests that gap every month.
  • Assumptions: home prices +3.5% a year, rent +3% a year, investments 7% a year, 6% selling costs.

In year one, the buyer's net worth is well behind because closing and selling costs wipe out early equity. Rent rises every year while most of the buyer's cost is a fixed mortgage payment. Buying catches up and breaks even in year 8. By year 10, the buyer is ahead at about 259,100 against 242,600. By year 15, the gap is about 401,500 against 341,500.

Change one input — rent of 2,000 instead of 2,200 — and renting stays ahead for the full 30 years in this model. Small assumptions decide the outcome, which is why it is worth testing your own numbers rather than relying on a rule of thumb.

What tends to favour each option

Favours buyingFavours renting
Staying put for many yearsLikely to move within a few years
High rent relative to home pricesHigh home prices relative to rent
Low mortgage ratesHigh mortgage rates
Strong local price growthDisciplined investing of the difference

Housing is also a lifestyle decision: stability, control over your space and the hassle of maintenance all matter. Use the numbers to understand the cost of your preference rather than to replace it. If you buy, the extra loan payment calculator shows how to shorten the mortgage. If you rent, the compound interest visualizer shows what your invested down payment can become.

Frequently asked questions

Isn't rent just throwing money away?

Rent buys housing, just as mortgage interest, property tax, maintenance and insurance do for an owner. Those owner costs are also unrecoverable. The fair comparison is total unrecoverable costs plus what each side's spare cash earns, which is exactly what this calculator measures through net worth.

Why does buying usually look worse in the first few years?

Buying has large one-off costs: closing costs when you buy and agent or legal fees when you sell. Early mortgage payments are also mostly interest. It typically takes several years of price growth and principal repayment to recover those costs, which is why the break-even year matters if you might move.

What if I wouldn't actually invest the difference?

Then the model overstates renting. Its advantage depends on investing the down payment and any monthly savings. If you would spend that money, buying acts as forced saving and will usually come out ahead. Set the investment return to a low figure to see what happens when the difference is not invested well.

Does the calculator include taxes, mortgage insurance and interest deductions?

Yes, as optional settings under “Transaction costs, insurance & taxes”: a tax rate on investment gains, a tax on the home's sale gain, and mortgage interest relief at your marginal rate. They default to 0 because rules differ widely between countries. Mortgage insurance (PMI) applies automatically while you owe more than 80% of the price.

What home price growth should I assume?

Long-run house prices have tended to rise a little faster than general inflation in many countries, but local markets vary enormously and can fall for years. Try a cautious figure close to inflation, then a more optimistic one, and see whether your decision changes.